Under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, the failure to honor a cheque for insufficiency of funds or exceeding the arranged amount constitutes a criminal offense punishable by imprisonment of up to 2 years, a fine up to double the cheque amount, or both.
Essential Ingredients of the Offense
- The cheque was drawn on an account maintained by the drawer for discharge of a legally enforceable debt or liability.
- The cheque was presented to the bank within its validity period (3 months).
- The cheque was returned unpaid by the bank due to insufficient funds, “account closed”, “stop payment”, or similar dishonor reasons.
- The payee made a written demand for payment within 30 days of receiving the memo of dishonor.
- The drawer failed to make payment within 15 days of receiving the legal notice.
Step-by-Step Filing Procedure
1.Receive Cheque Return Memo:Trigger point for statutory timeline.
Obtain the original dishonored cheque along with the official Return Memo from the banker stating the reason for dishonor (e.g., “Funds Insufficient”).
2.Issue Statutory Legal Notice:Must be sent within 30 days of bank memo.
Draft and issue a formal legal notice to the drawer under Section 138(b) via Registered Post AD or Speed Post, demanding the exact cheque amount within 15 days of receipt. Preserve postal receipts and delivery track reports.
3.Wait for 15-Day Cure Period:Mandatory waiting period.
Allow 15 days from the date of service of the legal notice for the drawer to pay. The cause of action arises only on the 16th day if no payment is made.
4.File Criminal Complaint in Court:Within 30 days after cause of action arises.
Draft the criminal complaint under Section 138 read with Section 142 of the NI Act and file it before the Judicial Magistrate First Class (JMFC) or Metropolitan Magistrate having territorial jurisdiction (determined by the location of the payee’s bank branch under Section 142(2)).
5.Cognizance and Pre-Summoning Evidence:Section 145 NI Act examination.
The Complainant submits an Affidavit of Evidence under Section 145 along with original documents (Cheque, Return Memo, Legal Notice, Postal Receipts, Track Reports). The Court takes cognizance and issues summons to the accused.
2. Defense of the Accused under Section 138 NI Act
While Sections 139 and 118(a) of the NI Act create mandatory legal presumptions that the cheque was issued for the discharge of a debt or liability, this presumption is rebuttable. The accused does not need to prove their defense beyond a reasonable doubt; establishing a preponderance of probabilities suffices (Rangappa v. Sri Mohan).
Major Lines of Defense
| Defense Head | Statutory / Legal Basis | Operational Details |
| No Legally Enforceable Debt | Section 138 Main Provision | Proving the cheque was given as security, for an illegal transaction, an unenforceable time-barred debt, or without consideration. |
| Defective Legal Notice | Section 138(b) | Notice issued beyond 30 days of bank memo, sent to incorrect address, or demanding an arbitrary sum without clearly segregating the cheque amount. |
| Limitation Barred Complaint | Section 142(1)(b) | Complaint filed beyond 30 days from the expiry of the 15-day notice period without a valid condonation of delay application. |
| Misuse of Security Cheque | Section 139 Rebuttal | Demonstrating that an undated security cheque given for a specific business/loan transaction was misused despite obligations being fulfilled. |
| Material Alteration / Fraud | Section 87 NI Act | Unauthorized changes in amount, date, or payee name without the drawer’s consent/attestation. |
| Lack of Territorial Jurisdiction | Section 142(2) | Case instituted in a court branch outside the payee’s bank branch location where the cheque was presented for clearing. |
| Lack of Corporate Vicarious Liability | Section 141 NI Act | If drawn by a company, failure to array the company as a primary accused, or suing a director who was not in charge of day-to-day operations at the time of offense. |
3. Settlement Procedure in NI Act Matters
Offenses under Section 138 are compoundable under Section 147 of the Negotiable Instruments Act read with Section 320 of the CrPC/BNSS. Courts strongly encourage compounding and settlement at any stage of proceedings.
Key Settlement Mechanisms
- Pre-Trial / Lok Adalat Settlement:
- Matters referred to National Lok Adalat or Mediation Center at the initial stage.
- Parties sign a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) or Consent Terms detailing installment dates, reduced compensation, or full payment.
- Upon receipt of the agreed amount, the Complainant files an application under Section 147 to compound the offense, leading to acquittal under Section 320 CrPC / BNSS.
- Interim Compensation (Section 143A NI Act):
- The Court can order the drawer to pay up to 20% of the cheque amount as interim compensation during trial (to be refunded with interest if acquitted).
- Settlement Post-Conviction / Appeal Stage:
- Compounding is permitted even at the Appellate or High Court/Supreme Court stage (Damodar S. Prabhu v. Sayed Babalal H.).
- Graduated Graded Costs Guidelines: Courts impose costs on late settlements to discourage delay:
- Trial Court Stage: No penalty / minimal cost.
- Sessions Court (Appeal) Stage: 10% of cheque amount as costs.
- High Court / Supreme Court Stage: 15% to 20% of cheque amount as costs payable to the Legal Services Authority.